Document a Day: Not Even if Ordered

The FBI wasn't alone in rejecting torture. One of the most dramatic and stirring of all the torture documents, this Statement for the Record from the Navy's top lawyer, Alberto Mora, chronicles a rebellion within the Defense Department against the  Donald  Rumsfeld-approved, Survival,  Evasion  Resist  Escape (SERE)-based torture methods.

When Naval Criminal Investigation Services (NCIS) agents first heard reports of  Mohammed  al Qahtani's interrogation on December 17, 2002, Mora relates, they “regarded such treatment as unlawful and in violation of American values.” In a meeting the following day, NCIS Director David Brant announced that  N avy interrogators “would not engage in the abusive practices even if ordered.”

Mora himself went face-to-face with Defense Department General Counsel Jim Haynes, and prepared a memo concluding that many of the techniques Rumsfeld had approved violated U.S. and international laws banning torture and cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment. When Mora threatened to sign and circulate the memo unless the use of the techniques was suspended, Rumsfeld blinked, officially withdrawing his December 2, 2002 authorization.






© ACLU, 125 Broad Street, 18th Floor, New York NY 10004

This is the website of the American Civil Liberties Union and the ACLU Foundation. Learn more about these two components of the ACLU.